AssurantMake A PaymentFile a Claim / 800-423-4403 Option 3 Auto-OwnersMake A PaymentFile a Claim / 888-252-4626 GeoVeraMake A PaymentFile a Claim / 877-642-1815 NationwideMake A PaymentFile a Claim / 800-421-3535 SafecoMake A PaymentFile a Claim / 800-332-3226 SelectiveMake A PaymentFile a Claim / 866-455-9969 TravelersMake A PaymentFile a Claim / 800-252-4633